Looking at both of the sites: Last Meal
Project and No Seconds, they provide quite different takes on what all
inmates received. No seconds shows more quality pictures of the food, that the
inmates eat, and this provides a clearer picture of what they asked for.
Actually seeing what a black olive with a pit in it makes for a very powerful
meaning. Why would you eat an olive as your last meal? The last meal project,
in turn, shows more factual information, including laws and reforms involving
the death penalty and last meal.
The author of the last meal project close to g the
more factual road, and with t, the less imaginative one. While it works well,
it doesn't invoke fiery emotions about the pictures. The cartoony pictures take
away from it, and is a little too rhetorical, and takes away the professional
aspect of all the presentation.
In The Last Meal project, the author is trying to
inform and show what kind of food they ate, and informing about the new laws as
it goes through. There is much more focus on the inmate themselves, with the
food lying as a back drop, and not the focal point. The author is trying to
show what person chooses what, to see what they look like, as to maybe provide
some insight on why they chose to eat said food.
The author of no seconds goes the better route, in
my opinion. Using pictures to do most of the talking, and words only to
identify everything, this makes all of the presentation seem more cohesive, and
go with the theme a little better. It seems more serious.
No Seconds put all the emphasis on the food that
was chosen, not the one that chose it at all. Showing no pictures of the
inmate, only saying their name and their charge of crime. The author is trying
to show how the crime committed can affect the food that was chosen.
I think that No Seconds drives a harder, and more
compelling argument and presentation. When I look at the pictures of the food,
and compare it to the crime, it is weird to see such a difference from what I
would think about. They both show rhetoric, and I think another presentation
could be made by showing the name, and how much the meal costs. This gives an
idea of how being on death row affects what we want as a person.
No comments:
Post a Comment